Geneva Gelato, Geneva, NY Geneva Gelato, located on Exchange Street in Geneva, NY is a full-service, authentic Italian Cafe specializing in Gelato & Sorbet. They are on a mission to provide their guests with a memorable & unique experience while using fresh local ingredients. They also offer a selection of Italian coffees, teas & other tasty Italian pasteries. Catering is also available. Stop in to see what all the fuss is about and enjoy a taste of Italy right here in the Finger Lakes. Geneva Gelato, created in Italy, perfected in Geneva.